AIP-505: Improving Funding Allocations To Benefit The DAO

PROPOSAL NAME

Improving Funding Allocations To Benefit The DAO

TEAM DESCRIPTION

@SmartAPE | DAO member [Trust Level 3] | writer-of-many-words

I am an indie software developer who has been in the games industry as a gamer and game dev for over 40 years. I have designed, developed, and published over a dozen games during my career.

My first game, Battlecruiser 3000AD (aka BC3K), was a ground-breaking game that was ahead of its time. Published by Take Two interactive in 1996, it was one of their portfolio titles when they went public in 1997. So, you could say that I helped the company succeed to where it is today.

Over the decades, I have worked with some of best software developers and publishers around the world, and my works have been featured in various online and print magazines around the world.

I am also a lifetime member of the International Game Developers Association, and was Florida chapter board member for several years.

You can learn more about me on my professional LinkedIn page.

PROPOSAL DESCRIPTION

As the DAO enters into a new era which will determine its future chances of survival, it is imperative that a clear distinction be made between grants, revenue share, and investments, and to manage the outflow of funds from the treasury which don’t have an inflow of revenue.

A proposal author or business entity that is 1) either a pre-existing revenue generating for-profit business or intends to set one up as per the proposal, and 2) which is requesting up to $100K in funding, commits to giving the DAO a percentage of its gross revenues, and such revenue share will be indicated in the proposal. If the proposal passes at vote, then the final revenue share percentage will be negotiated in good faith with the APE Foundation on a case by case basis.

Any proposal that requires funding of $100K or higher for revenue generating activity, is required to submit directly to the Banana Bill fund setup by AIP-454: The BANANA Bill: Apes Gotta Eat. Such authors are to be directed to the Banana Bill application form where, upon approval by the fund, they will enter into a formal commercial agreement as required.

The DAO will no longer issue grants (no revenue share with the DAO) for amounts greater than $50K. NOTE: Grant requests made by stewards of the DAO and which are to fund their operational costs, payments and DAO related programs. are exempt from this rule.

The AIP ideas and draft templates are to reflect the above conditions in the relevant BENEFIT TO THE APECOIN ECOSYSTEM and OVERALL COST sections so that author(s) are aware of these conditions prior to their submitting a proposal.

The AIP ideas and draft templates are to have a new section following the PROPOSAL NAME section, named FUNDING TYPE. The valid types are: GRANT, REVENUE SHARE, or INVESTMENT.

BENEFIT TO APECOIN ECOSYSTEM

The DAO treasury is rapidly declining - alongside the $ape token. At the current rate of spending and with all AIP allocations taken into account thus far, the DAO is expected to no longer be a going concern within a span of 19 months.

Oh, and btw, we barely have $100M left of disposable funds in the treasury. The treasury dashboard doesn’t take into account pre-allocated treasury funds set aside for approved AIPs (e.g. $100M Banana Bill)

In other words, going forward, the DAO needs number to go up. And the only way that can happen is via sustainable revenue generating activities - preferably short-term ones with the 3 - 12 months time frame.

DEFINITIONS

GRANT: A grant is a financial award provided by an organization, government, or individual to support a specific project, initiative, or cause. Unlike a loan, grants generally do not require repayment. They are often used to fund research, education, community projects, or other activities that align with the goals of the grant provider. Grants can be awarded to individuals, nonprofit organizations, educational institutions, or businesses, depending on the purpose and criteria of the grant. The recipient usually has to meet certain conditions or follow specific guidelines outlined in the grant agreement.

INVESTMENT: A financial investment is the allocation of money or resources into assets or ventures with the expectation of generating a profit or achieving a financial return over time. Investments can take various forms, including stocks, real estate, business ventures, cryptocurrency etc. The goal of a financial investment is typically to grow wealth, generate income, or achieve specific financial objectives. However, investments carry varying levels of risk, and it’s important for investors to assess their risk tolerance and conduct thorough research before committing funds.

REVENUE SHARE: A revenue share agreement is a business arrangement where one party agrees to share a portion of the revenue generated from a particular venture, project, or business activity with another party. This type of agreement is often used in various contexts, such as partnerships, licensing, affiliate marketing etc. Key aspects of a revenue share agreement typically include:

  • Revenue Percentage: The specific percentage or amount of revenue that will be shared.
  • Calculation Method: How the revenue is calculated and reported.
  • Payment Schedule: When and how often payments will be made.
  • Duration: The term of the agreement and any conditions for renewal or termination.
  • Roles and Responsibilities: The obligations of each party involved in the agreement.

Revenue share agreements can align interests and incentivize performance, as each party benefits from the success of the venture. However, it’s important for all parties to clearly define the terms and conditions to avoid misunderstandings and disputes.

STEPS TO IMPLEMENT

  1. All AIPs entering the draft phase and which are by for-profit person(s) or entities, are required to indicate that the DAO will receive a percentage of its revenue from “Gross Revenue/Receipts” in the BENEFIT TO APECOIN ECOSYSTEM section of the proposal.

  2. All AIPs entering the draft phase and which are requesting funds in excess of $100K in the OVERALL COST section of the proposal, are to be rejected, and the author(s) directed to the Banana Bill application form.

  3. All AIPs entering the draft phase and which are requesting grant (no revenue share to the DAO) funds in excess of $50K in the OVERALL COST section of the proposal, are to be rejected. NOTE: Grant requests made by stewards of the DAO and which are to fund their operational costs, payments etc. are exempt from this rule.

  4. The AIP ideas and draft templates are to reflect the above conditions in the relevant BENEFIT TO THE APECOIN ECOSYSTEM and OVERALL COST sections so that author(s) are aware of these conditions prior to their submitted a proposal.

  5. The AIP ideas and draft templates are to have a new section following the PROPOSAL NAME section, named FUNDING TYPE. The valid types are: GRANT, REVENUE SHARE, or INVESTMENT. For example: “FUNDING TYPE: Grant”

  6. All AIPs entering the Draft phase with an Overall Cost designated in $APE (or non-USD denomination) would have the USD value of their request “locked in,” and would be reported for the community in the AIP’s Overall Cost section.

  7. Should the Banana Bill run out of funds, then unless and until another such fund is setup, it will be up to the Special Council to determine whether or not to enter into a commercial agreement with proposals exceeding $100K and which have passed at vote. This decision would be based on a majority vote of all 5 members of the Special Council.

REPORTING EXPECTATIONS

The expectation is that this proposal would be implemented by the DAO’s administrative team.

The community should regularly review the impact of this proposal.

If accepted, the administration and the community should review the impact of the updates after the 3-month period for conflict ends.

OVERALL COST

Total amount requested from the ApeCoin Ecosystem Fund = No Cost

The APE Foundation is responsible for any administrative costs in implementing this proposal.

1 Like

Hi @SmartAPE ,

The community feedback period for your proposal would be ending in roughly 28 hours.

  • If you’re content with the feedback received, your next steps are to finalize your proposal using the AIP Draft Template.

  • A moderator will reach out to the author to finalize the AIP Draft. Upon receipt of the final Draft, we will review and provide instructions on the next steps.

  • Are you ready to proceed to the next phase or do you wish to extend community discussion for another 7 days?

We look forward to hearing from you.

-@Facilitators

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed after 7 days. New replies are no longer allowed.

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

@SmartAPE has completed editing their AIP Idea to be their AIP Draft.

This proposal has been assigned the AIP ID Number 505.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

1 Like

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

Our team has reviewed and discussed @SmartAPE 's AIP Draft and have sent a list of initial questions. We await answers.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

1 Like

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

@SmartAPE has responded to our questions and they are in our review once again.

Additionally, edits have been made to this Topic, by the author, by the author’s request, or with the author’s consent.

You can click the Pencil icon at the top of the post to see these edits.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

1 Like

As this is written, it would apply to all the Working Group Non Profit AIPs. Is this your intention?

Are their salaries considered grants? If so, under what jurisdiction are grants now considered salaries or 1099 (contract work-for-hire)?

If they are grants, this should have been pointed out during admin review so that I could revise the proposal to exclude working groups and such.

@12GAUGE

1 Like

No one is a salaried employee from a Working Group by the Cayman Foundation. Working Group budgets are AIP grant recipients. All Compensation for Stewards is paid by the respective WG Non profit Dao LLCs who receive those AIP grants.

1 Like

I am aware that the WG put up their budgets. And that’s used to compensate individuals. But those individuals still have to pay taxes regardless of the entity structure that is paying them. That’s why I was asking about their engagement status (employee or contractor) because grants aren’t generally tax exempt to individuals, only to non-prof.

Anyway, that was a side note because I didn’t take into account that those payments weren’t treated like direct payments to other third-party contractors, and thus unaffected by the grant caps in this proposal.

I will revise the proposal to exclude WGs from the limits, thus making it clearer.

1 Like

Is there something missing between > $50k to < $100k ?

I picked the numbers based on the average of the grant amounts thus far allocated to projects that I deemed to be credible. From that I deduced that $50K was the sweet spot for grants. And anything above that and up to $100K would be investments which would return revenue to the DAO. And above $100K would go to BB (which is mostly for ApeChain growth).

1 Like

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

Edits have been made to this Topic, by the author, by the author’s request, or with the author’s consent.

You can click the Pencil icon at the top of the post to see these edits.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

1 Like