AIP-395: .APE - Launching the Real .APE Top-Level Domain on the Internet

Hi @staypuft,

Thank you for your ideas [and the ApeCoin DAO community for the insightful discussions].

A moderator will reach out to the author to finalize the AIP Draft using the appropriate template.

  • Once the AIP Draft is confirmed by the author and meets all DAO-approved guidelines, it will receive an AIP ID number and move forward for Draft Analysis Review.
  • @staypuft please see your messages for the next steps.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments. In accordance with DAO-approved guidelines, if the author does not respond within 30 days, the proposal will be automatically transferred to the Withdrawn category, and the author can re-submit the idea.

-@Facilitators

2 Likes

This topic was automatically closed after 7 days. New replies are no longer allowed.

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

Edits have been made to this Topic, by the author or by the author’s request.

You can click the Pencil icon at the top of the post to see these edits.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

2 Likes

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

@staypuft has completed editing their AIP Idea to be their AIP Draft.

This proposal has been assigned the AIP ID Number 395.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

2 Likes

Can you give a comment on this. Appreciate it.

https://www.coinspeaker.com/ens-godaddy-web3-integration/

2 Likes

The .ETH TLD doesn’t resolve to the DNS system, so ENS has a rich history of supporting DNS integrations for over 6 years. One of our co-founders from .XYZ pioneered this integration with ENS via DNS TXT records in 2018, followed by Namecheap in 2021, and now GoDaddy is joining the trend. This collaboration underscores the marketing potential for both GoDaddy and ENS, showcasing the broader possibilities with TXT records, which is beneficial for real DNS domains like .APE.

TLDR

All this further demonstrates the importance of DNS TXT records for blockchain interoperability. We’re excited about this advancement and look forward to more registrars embracing blockchain interoperability through TXT records, including .APE.

9 Likes

Very well said @ShaneCultra and I fully agree with this! :handshake:

2 Likes

Overall interesting idea and hope this moves forward! :white_check_mark:

3 Likes

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

Our team has reviewed and discussed @staypuft’s AIP Draft and have sent a list of initial questions. We await answers.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

2 Likes

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

@staypuft has responded to our questions and they are in our review once again.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

Edits have been made to this Topic, by the author or by the author’s request.

You can click the Pencil icon at the top of the post to see these edits.

@staypuft has responded to our questions and has provided consent to share them in this forum for the community.

1. What are the expectations of the Ape Foundation in regards to the ongoing partnership, preparation of the ICANN application, and any of the other steps of the AIP implementation? Please specify the steps and elaborate on the expectations of the Foundation for each step.

Agreement confirming Ape Foundation’s representation of the ApeCoin community, brand, and trademark, and exclusivity for D3 to act on behalf of Ape Foundation, through ApeCoin DAO, to apply for the .APE top-level domain.

2. Would the Foundation be expected to maintain custody of any newly created assets on behalf of the ApeCoin DAO community?

Name tokens are tokenized, and holders will be able to self-custody from the D3 once created, if desired.

3. Please elaborate on your expectations for the future ownership of any content that may be produced as a result of this proposal. Clarify your expectations for any ApeCoin trademark requests.

There will be extensive co-marketing campaigns, and the ApeCoin DAO will be consulted and given access to content calendars and other marketing and branding materials for approval where the brand, its imagery and trademarks are mentioned or displayed.

4. Please verify your status as “accredited TLD registry operators.”

Our affiliate company, Internet Naming Co. is wholly owned by our co-founder Shayan Rostam. Internet Naming Co. is the ICANN-accredited registry operator of .click, .country, .diy, .food, .hiv, .lifestyle, .living, .realty, .vana, and more, as verified on the ICANN and IANA websites:

.click Registry Agreement

.realty Registry Agreement

.diy Domain Delegation Data

.food Domain Delegation Data

We are in the process of expanding a registry assignment for our newly-formed D3 entity. We expect this to be completed in 30-45 days.

5. Please revise your Steps to Implement and Timeline section. The AIP Draft template sets the expectation for these sections to be formatted into a single section. Our suggestion would be to simply adjust the headline title to the expected title “Steps to Implement and Timeline”, and adjust the font for the section currently labelled Timeline so that it would not be viewed as a separate section. We can help with this.

You may update the section title as suggested.

6. Please include a Platforms and Technology section. As specified by the AIP Draft Template, this would include a detailed breakdown of the platforms and technologies that are to be used.

D3’s registry and registrar will require DNS and database infrastructure, along with software to facilitate domain management workflows and integration with each other:

Registry Scope:

  1. Compliant registry backend system
  2. Maintain DNS servers and zone file access
  3. Pricing and registration data services
  • Escrow and data protection
  • Monitor operations and generate abuse reports
  • Ongoing ICANN compliance requirements

Registry Technologies:

  • DNS servers
  • Database
  • Provisioning system
  • Monitoring and reporting tools
  • Security and cloud protection

Registrar Scope:

  • Provide registrar website and console
  • Manage customer and domain registration data
  • Integrate with registry system
  • Facilitate customer payments
  • Ongoing ICANN compliance requirements

Registrar Technologies:

  • Servers and database
  • Protocol client software
  • Web frameworks and payment gateway
  • DNS integration
  • Blockchain integrations

7. The image under your Motivation section mentions “profit sharing”. In alignment with the rest of your proposal, can you revise the graphic to indicate “revenue share”?

We can provide an updated image, attached.

8. Would the application for “the real .APE TLD” be submitted as a Generic TLD or Sponsored TLD?

.APE would be a generic TLD, just like .XYZ or .APP. Sponsored TLDs are a category of generic TLD. Due to the public nature of this review process, and the high stakes and sizable investment involved in acquiring a TLD, we prefer to keep our acquisition strategy confidential at this time.

9. Will D3 be transferring ownership of the .APE asset to the ApeCoin DAO if awarded the TLD?

It is not possible for any entity or individual to “own” a TLD. ICANN contractually grants the rights to exclusively operate and monetize each TLD that automatically renews every 10 years. This is true of every ICANN-accredited gTLD, including .com and .xyz. In order for the ApeCoin DAO to take advantage of the benefits the D3 team offers as an existing ICANN-accredited registry operator (e.g. expedited application and minimal diligence on the DAO and the Foundation), D3 must be the TLD applicant and contracted registry operator with ICANN. This also means that D3 will take on the onerous ongoing registry obligations (e.g. annual audits, compliance, etc) to ensure .APE remains in good standing. D3 acts as essentially the white-glove and full-service operator for .APE. ApeCoin DAO and the Foundation will maintain a vested interest and voice in all TLD operations, including pricing strategy, launch timeline, whitelists and blacklists, and more. Should the Foundation desire to create its own entity and maintain the complex ongoing registry obligations, D3 will be happy to facilitate the transfer for the .APE TLD once approved.

10. “D3 will pledge 50% of all net revenues generated back to the ApeCoin DAO.”

a. Is there an expected schedule for the distribution of this revenue back to the DAO treasury?

This is flexible, however we typically recommend disbursements on a monthly, quarterly, or annual basis.

b. Do you propose revenues to be returned to the DAO treasury in the form of $APE, or an alternative token?

The DAO can opt to receive revenue in fiat (USD) or a dedicated stablecoin (USDT or USDC).

11. The “Key Assumptions” portion beneath your “Illustrative Revenue Projection” chart mentions an “Initial ramp of 10% of ~130K APE wallet holders purchasing domains, growing yearly,” yet the Year 1 chart figure illustrates 13K wallets, growing yearly up to 90k wallets in Year 4. Please clarify these figures.

As outlined in the ‘Illustrative Revenue Projection’ imagery, 10% of 130,000 is the 13,000. These figures are expected to grow to include Web3 users outside of the ApeCoin community and eventually Web2 once the TLD is launched.

12. “Members of the ApeCoin community will have the exclusive opportunity to gain early access to other APE name tokens before they are made available to the public.”

a. How would the community be informed of this opportunity?

There will be a pre-launch phase where the community will be informed through thorough marketing initiatives, communication from community stakeholders as well as the official ApeCoin channels to maximize exposure to the ApeCoin community.

b. What are the eligibility requirements to participate?

In order for a user to be eligible for the exclusive early access phase, they will need to hold either $APE, a BAYC or MAYC NFT.

c. What would the process to access these name tokens look like?

*Users will need to create an account on D3 where they will be able to search for and register any available APE name they are interested in.

4. If web3 wallet connectivity is required, what are the plans for security audits of the platform?

We are currently integrated with MetaMask, WalletConnect, and Thirdweb, which collectively support more than 170 wallets. We will continue to add additional integrations which expand the security and accessibility of the TLD.

13. “In the highly unlikely event that D3 does not successfully acquire the right to operate .APE, owners of Ape Names at the time of notice will be eligible for a full refund on the primary registration fee associated with each token.” Please elaborate.

Users who hold the name token at the time of notice will be eligible for a refund on the initial registration fee at the first point of sale for the name. For example, if User A purchases hello [star] ape for 10 USDC, trades it to User B, User B will be eligible for the refund of 10 USDC at the time of notice. We conduct the necessary KYT (Know your transaction) and KYC (Know your customer) operations on any monetary flows through our platform to maintain the proper compliance as a registry.

14. Are you requesting the entirety of funding up front, or are you willing to accept fund disbursement in tranches if your proposal is approved?

We’re requesting an upfront commitment by ApeCoin DAO to enable us to plan large scale, wide global activation of the name token sale while concurrently initiating the ICANN application process with our staff and legal which requires more than 12 months of preparation (500+ page application), and initiate IRL activations which often require deposits.

15. Your Overall Cost section gives an overview of your “estimated budget”.
Please update your Overall Cost section to specify the exact grant request.

Please update to Allocated Funds, and add footnote: “Any remaining excess funds will be directed towards revenue-generating activities including performance-based marketing and sales.”

16. As per the ApeCoin General Guidelines, “proposals will not be put up for vote if they involve illegal activity, hate speech, pornographic material, or are at odds with the mission or values of the APE Foundation.” Can you ensure that the content of the domain names and the name tokens will be in keeping with these guidelines?

Yes. Our standard Acceptable Use Policies already prohibit illegal activity, hate speech, domain abuse, etc. We are also able to work with members of the ApeCoin community to add tailored policies for [star]APE and .APE, including but not limited to prohibiting content that is pornographic or violates the mission or values of the APE Foundation.

17. Do you provide consent to apply updates to the relevant areas of your proposal based on your responses to the questions above?

Yes, I consent to making the necessary updates as requested.

18. Do you provide consent to share these questions and answers with the community in this forum?

Yes, I consent to sharing these questions and answers with the ApeCoin community on the forum.

A DAR package is being worked on and upon completion this AIP will move into Administrative Review. Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

1 Like

Hi ApeCoin DAO Community,

We have no further questions for @staypuft. This AIP is now under Administrative Review.

Follow this Topic as further updates will be posted here in the comments.

Kind Regards,

-@Facilitators

1 Like

Showing great promise. Best of luck with it.

5 Likes

This looks very promising

3 Likes

How does this compare to what pudgy did launching on unstoppable domains this week?

1 Like

Hey @bigbull -

Great question and glad you brought this up! Check out the comparison table between DNS Domains and Web3 Names in the proposal. Web3 Names, while great for display, possess critical shortcomings including name collisions… a huge risk for the end user where two or more identifiers in a given namespace or scope cannot be unambiguously resolved.

Without working with a real Internet registry operator, Pudgy Penguins and its namespace will expose and operate in a fashion that solicits the sale of Pudgy names without them ever being genuine domains with native resolution via the DNS, universally across all browsers and devices (no integrations required). A few examples of reputational and commercial risks created by doing so include the .COIN and .WALLET campaigns, which UD initially launched and soon after encountered name collisions – .COIN is no longer supported and they’re now in heavy litigation for .WALLET.

Our proposal, to pursue the real .APE, avoids these risks altogether by unifying the DNS and blockchain to provide universal access and resolution. As we’ve highlighted, the DNS is deeply embedded in every single Internet user’s daily life. We use and interact with domain names when we do anything digitally. That level of integration and universal support is what we’re proposing for .APE.

To summarize, a unified .APE on the DNS+Web3 would offer:

  • Real-world asset with IRL+ on-chain utility
  • Easily accessible by over 5 billion Internet users
  • Consistent, recurring revenue for the ApeCoin DAO
  • Single source of truth against ‘fake’ names and scams
  • Usable across Web1, Web2, Web3 and beyond

We want to bring real, authentic domains to the ApeCoin ecosystem by securing the real .APE TLD. The DNS has been around for 30+ years, so this should offer some insight into the significance and sustainability of utility and revenue generation for the DAO in .APE.

Let’s make .APE the next .XYZ! :grinning:

5 Likes

I love the ideal might be worth exploring the Apecoin dao needs more exposure

4 Likes

Hey thanks for the proposal team, I have a few concerns to address;

  1. The allocation of funds for marketing is high in comparison to other proposals, while I understand exposure is a key part of growth. The D3 brand looks as though it has not demonstrated marketing prowess across their existing brand assets in Web3. (correct me if i’m wrong)

How are you going to take market share within this space and why would we (ApeDao) not leverage exposure of existing projects/brands with a stronger presence? (Please provide a better understanding of your GTM strategy)

  1. Having a centralized authority, in this case ICANN, whilst acting as a public good to prevent domain name collisions, they still have control to the extent their is an application window and requirement for 500 pages of application filing.

Innovative Web3 entrepreneurs are creating ways to avoid Web3 domain name collisions occurring, the most recent example being Freename launching the NOTO Protocol > Freename Launches NOTO: The Protocol That Makes Web3 Internet Accessible and Interoperable to All – Silent PR Bitcoin News

As the Web3 domain name space matures, having a decentralized approach to domain name space issuance will develop out of necessity to fulfill the Web3 ideals.

  1. Regarding Web3 domain name integrations into existing web2 infrastructure, browser integrations are already on their way, while friction points still remain, it’s only a matter of time before these are reduced, again out of necessity.

More info on how browser integrations have been implemented with ENS can be found here ENS (.eth) Browser Support

Some examples of where this implementation is taking place. e.g. (https://vitalik.eth/) & (https://eth.limo/) and for decentralized email service providers; you can check out Dmail & Ethermail (List of 11 Web3 Email Tools (2023) - Alchemy)

Given the speed of development within this space, it’s only a matter of time before Web3 domain integrations & tools become mainstream.

  1. And arguably the most important aspect is security, forgive me if i’ve missed the section where you spoke about this, but who are your auditing and security partners? Can you provide an audit report?

  2. You briefly mentioned a token will be implemented alongside the domain launch process, would love to hear more about this, really good idea but can you provide some more info on the token economics, maybe a green paper or article outlining in more detail how this would work?

Looking forward to your response :slight_smile:

4 Likes

Really good aip, love the idea

1 Like