I shared my thoughts about this in another post and I agree with your points. It has gotten some support from both BAYC and MAYC hodlers along with $APE hodlers.
Post & Comment : https://forum.apecoin.com/t/aip-5-staking-proposal-discussion/3184/11?u=fiyu
What have I said:
We love BAYC, MAYC, and BAKC. But there is something important being constantly forgotten:
Apecoin DAO isn’t Yugalabs, nor is it run by Yugalabs and Yugalabs has no responsibility for Apecoin DAO as they stated.
We need educated people about that first to move forward.
Furthermore,
The notion of giving staking opportunities to BAYC, MAYC, and KAYC is an unfair toll on Apecoin DAO.
The %15 airdrop was a fair headstart but Apecoin DAO shouldn’t be subjected to carrying BAYC, MAYC, and KAYC holders through its entire existence.
It is now a decentralized entity that is gifted to the community to run, it can & should rhyme with Yugalabs values and incentives although it shouldn’t constantly supplement it.
Disclaimer: I only hold $APECOIN, so there is a little bit of principal-agent problem there.
So, I would love to hear the opinions of BAYC and MAYC holders.