Explain This Like I'm Five. WHY are AIPs sent to vote out of order?

This has bugged me for some time now. And in speaking to others - who, for obvious reasons haven’t actually publicly voiced it - I am not alone.

Why are proposals sent to vote out of order?

e.g. Since June 21, I have written…[checks notes]…18 (!!) proposals.

AIP-???: Streamline Proposal Times and Reporting
AIP-???: Update treasury dashboard to reflect pre-allocated funds
AIP-???: Update AIP Tracking Data
AIP-???: Improving Funding Allocations To Benefit The DAO
AIP-???: APE Foundation DAO Transparency Reports
AIP-497: Restore Elections Data Visibility
AIP-487: ApeCoin Community Engagement Platform
AIP-478: Require Ape Foundation To Disburse AIP Funds In Timely Fashion
AIP-477: Special Council To Clarify The APE Foundation
AIP-476: ApeCoin Gaming Sub-Domains
AIP-475: Fast Track Proposals and Enforce Leadership Transparency
AIP-474: Delegated ApeCoin Community Voting Wallet
AIP-471: Special Council To Propose Voting System Reform
AIP-469: Ape Foundation To Clarify Ability To Terminate Contracts
AIP-467: Proposal To Revise Special Council & WG Stewards Term Limits
AIP-466: Proposal To Close Non-Essential Working Groups
AIP-465: Alignment Of Working Group Terms And Budgets
AIP-464: Future Election Leadership Requirements

And before you say "It depends on the author", yes, that can be the case. But how does that explain the fact that, in my case, there hasn’t been a single time whereby info was requested by the facilitators or the Special Council regarding my proposals and I haven’t responded in a timely fashion. In fact - and I checked this in the message stream - there hasn’t been an instance whereby I didn’t respond to a proposal query within a 24 hr period.

To wit:

Yesterday’s voting cycle has the following proposals:

p-date = date proposal first posted
f-date = date final material response/change added to the proposal
v-date = date proposal sent to vote

AIP P-DATE F-DATE V-DATE
AIP-489: Restoring Balance 07/03/24 07/22/24 08/15/24
AIP-481: Building the Modular IP Layer with ApeCoin 06/27/24 07/30/24 08/15/24
AIP-474: Delegated ApeCoin Community Voting Wallet 06/24/04 07/18/24 08/15/24
AIP-472: ApeLance: WEB3 Freelance Marketplace on ApeChain 06/23/24 07/23/24 08/15/24
AIP-468: Bored Trading Co Powered By ApeCoin 06/28/24 07/18/24 08/15/24
AIP-463: Empowering Otherside Wiki 06/19/24 07/16/24 08/15/24
AIP-457: The Public Bored - Phase 2 06/13/24 07/24/24 08/15/24

While there are instances whereby some otherwise completed proposals require follow-up from the facilitators, that’s immaterial to the queue itself when you look at the time lapse between the last material (critical revisions) response, the creation date, and the voting date.

For example: With no more responses required for AIP-464 (06/19/24, 06/29/24), how is it that AIP-468 to AIP-489 are up for vote? :thinking:

We saw this happen with AIP-454 [Banana Bill] which went up on June 13th, and was up for vote on June 20th. However, with the impending release (currently delayed) of ApeChain, it made sense for this proposal and similar infra and/or vital proposals be sent to vote as soon as is reasonably possible. And because there was a lot of noise surrounding that proposal leapfrogging others, I wrote AIP-475 to make it official and to alleviate such musings related to such impactful proposals.

So, this doesn’t make any sense to me - at all. And so, I would very much like an explanation from the @Facilitators or the @Stewards_Governance

2 Likes

AIP implementation is administered by the Ape Foundation, and may be materially altered to optimize for security, usability, and to protect APE holders.

1 Like

Yes - I am aware, but that still doesn’t explain the out-of-order nature in most cases.

I know that you guys won’t have the answer, but why, for example, would my AIP-474 go to vote before AIP-458 (06/22/24), which is a re-submission of AIP-413? I have several other examples because before creating this topic for discussion, I created an entire table of proposals.

I wrote this proposal to provide this sort of insight. So, I hope that it passes and that it sheds more light on this mystery.